Quality of Hire: How to Know if You Hired a Top-Notch Employee

The recruitment and hiring processes are potentially time- and budget-draining endeavors for any organization, especially when done inefficiently. On the other hand, regular skills assessment tests and continuously refining your approach help you avoid unnecessary expenses.

One metric you can check to measure your recruitment strategy’s effectiveness is the quality of hire. Evaluating this metric protects you against the high costs of less-than-optimal recruitment decisions. It also fosters an environment where employees meaningfully contribute to your company’s success.

Let’s examine a few proven insights and tips on how to measure quality of hire so you can bring in top-notch talent who can drive your organization forward.

What is quality of hire? 

Quality of hire is a critical metric in assessing a newly employed team member’s value to a company. Beyond the initial skill match, quality of hire evaluates how well a top candidate aligns with your company culture, adapts to their roles, and contributes to broader organizational goals.

Measuring quality of hire means you’re not just filling a position; it’s about enhancing team dynamics and positively influencing company performance. Ensuring new employees contribute to your company’s success is paramount. The cost of a bad hire can affect productivity and can tank the bottom line.

5 Quality of Hire Metrics to Look at 

The first few months of a new team member’s employment is your opportunity to see their contributions and potential. Using the following quality-of-hire metrics will help you gain valuable insights into the effectiveness of your recruitment and hiring techniques. Sharing these insights through informal performance reviews also helps boost confidence in new employees, allowing them to experience success early in the relationship or make proactive course corrections to be a better contributor.

1. Ramp-up time

Ramp-up time refers to the period when new hires adjust to their roles and work environment before reaching full productivity. 

Shorter ramp-up times indicate that new employees learn and adapt fast, so they make meaningful contributions earlier than expected. Efficient onboarding processes and training programs can reduce ramp-up time and accelerate the return on investment (ROI) of hiring new employees.

2. Job performance and productivity

These indicators measure employees’ abilities to fulfill their duties and contribute to company goals throughout their employment. High-quality hires consistently demonstrate strong job performance and productivity in their roles, leading to increased revenue, improved customer satisfaction, and enhanced company reputation over time. This means the employee delivers value to your organization from the day they were hired until the day they resign.

3. Team feedback

Getting insights from teams working with new hires is crucial since these types of collaborations let you recognize an employee’s communication style and overall contribution to the team dynamic. Positive team feedback suggests that the new hire integrates well into the team and is a good culture fit. On a larger scale, this helps determine how the team’s dynamics are playing a role for company growth.

Consider getting feedback at the new hire’s 30, 60, and 90-day anniversary to assess their performance and improvement.

4. Client feedback

This metric is vital for customer-facing roles like sales associates, customer service representatives, and account managers. Favorable feedback from clients indicates that your new hire provides exceptional service, builds strong customer relationships, and contributes to customer satisfaction.

You may conduct surveys or directly ask clients about your team members’ performance.

5. Turnover rate

Employees who choose to stay for a long time can contribute more to your organization. For instance, they know the ins and outs of your workflows, so they can offer ideas on how to address bottlenecks in your processes.

Additionally, turnover rate is an overall metric of your ability to make smart hiring decisions. It tells you whether your recruiting and hiring system is working to bring in quality hires or not.  

To calculate the turnover rate in your company, use the following formula:

Monthly turnover (%) = (Employees separated / Average number of employees) x 100

A low turnover rate reduces recruitment and training costs and fosters a stable and productive work environment.

How to Measure Quality of Hire 

Assessing quality of hire is essential for making informed decisions about your recruitment and hiring process. Although you can use several formulas to get objective results, the goal is to derive an average from multiple indicators. The formula below is a good start:

Quality of Hire (%) = (Indicator % + Indicator %) / Number of Indicators

Let’s consider a scenario where you’re quantitatively assessing a new hire based on their job performance, ramp-up time, and team feedback—each scored out of 100, as seen below. 

• Job performance: 85/100
• Ramp-up time: 90/100
• Team feedback: 80/100

Now, let’s plot the numbers in the formula:

 (85% + 90% + 80%) / 3

Quality of Hire = 85%

The result indicates that your new hire performs well across the three metrics and significantly contributes to the company. 

Ultimately, high scores in quality of hire indicate that your new employees can deliver long-term value to your organization. Quality hires help you reduce your cost per hire since you no longer need to frequently restart your recruitment cycles, onboarding, and training programs, all of which cost time, money, and labor.

Land Quality Employees

Measuring quality of hire isn’t just a corporate formality—it’s a must-have tool for forming a team of competent and reliable employees. Strategically assessing your new hires can help you save time, effort, and money in the long run. The earlier you improve your recruitment and hiring processes, the easier it is for your company to reach its goals.

Find quality hires with EmployTest. Our pre-employment assessment tests help you spot top talent you won’t regret hiring. Try a free sample test today.