Reducing Recruitment Bias When Hiring Someone You Know

What is the Recruitment Bias?

Recruitment bias is the tendency to favor or disfavor certain candidates unfairly based on subjective traits like personal relationships instead of objective job qualifications. When hiring someone you know, unconscious biases around familiarity, affinity, and assumptions can cloud impartial evaluation of skills and fit.

When you spot a resume from your college friend or a past coworker, it’s difficult not to get excited. Bringing on people you know seems like a no-brainer because you already know their true skill sets and work ethics. Most of all, you trust them!

But before you make promises about job offers, put the brakes on! Hiring should always be about finding the best fit – not simply helping out friends.

Fortunately, you can use hiring best practices that prevent unconscious recruitment bias. This helps you make fair decisions based on merit and tap into your network’s diversity, instead of past relationships.

How Familiarity Can Cause Unconscious Bias in Hiring

Cognitive biases can significantly impact the candidate selection process, as admitted by 48% of HR managers. These biases can happen when evaluating applications from close friends or previous colleagues, compromising the objectivity of the decision-making process.

• Similarity bias happens when you overvalue common ground, leading to inflated cultural fit recommendations based on rapport, rather than skills.  This bias surfaces because we tend to favor people who are similar to us. However, this can lead to overlooking the skills and qualifications of other candidates who may be more qualified for the role. A number of surveys report that similarity bias is a significant factor in 78% of recruitment decisions.  
• Confirmation bias occurs when you prioritize qualifications that align with your existing opinions. For instance, when considering a friend or past coworker, you may only focus on their strengths and overlook their weaknesses, leading to biased decisions when hiring.
• Risk reduction bias is the tendency to avoid taking risks. This can lead us to bypass vetting and assume competence in candidates who are familiar to us. 
• Nepotism is the practice of favoring relatives in hiring decisions. This bias can occur even when the relatives are not qualified for the role. 

Blurred Boundaries

Mixing personal and professional relationships can make it challenging to maintain clear boundaries. When friends become employees, it can be difficult to separate personal matters from work-related issues,which can lead to conflicts and tension.

Limited Feedback

Telling a friend you’ve hired that they’re not meeting expectations or behaving inappropriately can be uncomfortable. It’s challenging for employers or HR managers to remain unbiased when addressing problem behavior in someone they care about.

Unprofessional Behavior

When friends or family members are hired, they may feel a sense of entitlement or special treatment. Unfortunately, this behavior can lead to unprofessionalism and a lack of respect for authority. Ultimately, this can have a negative impact on team dynamics and discipline in the workplace.

What are Other Examples of Unconscious Bias in Recruitment?

Here are some other examples of recruitment bias that can unconsciously creep into the recruitment process.

• Halo/Horns Effect – Allowing one positive (halo) or negative (horns) piece of information about a candidate to influence your overall perception of them. For example, attending a prestigious university could create a “halo” bias toward them.
• Beauty Bias – Study after study shows that physical attractiveness can positively influence hiring decisions, regardless of qualifications.
• Contrast Effect – When decision-makers evaluate candidates in sequence, they are more likely to be swayed by the performance of the candidates interviewed most recently.
• Name Bias – Unconsciously judging candidates based on subtle cues from their name, which can signal gender, ethnicity, social status, etc.
• Ageism – Unfairly discounting or stereotyping candidates based on their perceived age, whether too young or too old.

The bottom line? We all have unconscious biases. Recognizing them is the first step to smarter, fairer hiring that focuses solely on a candidate’s future potential value to the company.

Best Practices to Reduce Bias in the Hiring Process

Maintaining impartiality during the hiring process can be challenging when candidates have personal connections to the hiring team.

To address this, it’s important to establish hiring best practices that evaluate all applicants consistently and minimize the influence of biases.

Here are some effective strategies to reduce recruitment bias when hiring someone you know:

1.  Implement Blind Resume Reviews

Remove personally identifiable details from resumes, such as names, addresses, and gender, to prevent assumptions based on affinity or personal connections. This allows for a more objective assessment of the candidate’s qualifications and skills.

2. Incorporate Skills Testing

Use pre-employment tests to evaluate the candidate’s skills required for success in the job. These assessments serve as objective measures of a candidate’s talents and abilities, helping to identify the most suitable candidate based on merit rather than relying on personal relationships.

3. Conduct Panel Interviews

When interviewing someone you know, have someone else in the room or let someone else conduct the interview. Afterward, use clear scoring criteria that are benchmarked across all applicants to reduce individual biases and ensure an objective evaluation. This way, you can avoid personal biases and others won’t question your decision if you end up hiring your friend.

4. Focus on Merit-Centric Data Points

When hiring, focus on job-related factors like skills, experience, and cultural fit instead of personal connections. This will limit the impact of the personal relationship with anyone involved in the hiring process.

5. Be Mindful of Unconscious Bias

Recognize unconscious biases that may influence your decisions. Educate yourself about common biases and actively work to counteract them. Remain open to considering candidates from diverse backgrounds and experiences, even if they don’t fit the traditional mold.

6. Document the Hiring Process

Maintain detailed records of the selection process, including the criteria used for evaluation and the reasons behind hiring decisions. This documentation helps to ensure transparency and accountability and can be valuable in addressing any future claims of bias or discrimination.

If you want to hire the best candidates, focus on fairness and objectivity during the recruitment process. This will help you reduce bias and promote diversity, leading to better quality hires and overall success for your company.

Using Pre-Employment Tests to Avoid Bias When Hiring Someone You Know

Pre-employment testing is a valuable tool that you can use to reduce recruitment bias and ensure a fair and objective hiring process.

• Data-driven Insights: Pre-employment tests provide concrete data on candidates’ skills, enabling you to make informed hiring decisions based on objective performance.
  
• Fair and Consistent Evaluation: Skills tests ensure a fair and consistent evaluation process, reducing the impact of biases or personal preferences.
  
• Identify Top Candidates: Assessments help identify candidates with the skills and abilities that align closely with the requirements of the role.
  
• Improved Hiring Efficiency: By screening candidates based on their skills, you can streamline the hiring process and focus your efforts on the most promising candidates.
• Diversity: By using pre-employment tests, HR teams can widen their candidate pool and attract a more diverse workforce. Because tests are not influenced by personal relationships or biases, companies can focus on finding the best candidates for the job, regardless of their background.

Hiring someone you know can be a double-edged sword. By implementing hiring best practices and using best-in-class pre-employment tests, you can assess candidates’ abilities objectively. This way, you can minimize personal biases and make fair hiring decisions.

Transform your recruitment process – request a demo of our advanced testing platform!