EmployTest Logo

Essential Paralegal Skills: The Ultimate Guide to Hiring High-Quality Paralegals

Image of a woman testing for paralegal skills

As you know, finding a paralegal skills rich sidekick can be a real challenge. Those master multitaskers with an encyclopedic knowledge of case law are rare gems in the legal universe.

But, fear not! Your trusty HR Blog is here to share some powerful tips.

We want to help you recruit your next extraordinary paralegal and ensure their legal skills are up to even the most demanding of challenges.

Locating high-quality candidates with the right combination of paralegal skills, experience and knowledge can be difficult in any industry, but recruiting talented paralegals has a few challenges of its own. For one, working as a paralegal typically requires specialized training and expertise in case law, which can be hard to come by outside of higher education. In addition, the paralegal profession has expanded over the past few decades and now encompasses a range of different positions, according to AgileLaw. As a result, law firms have had to dedicate additional time and resources to verifying whether potential candidates match their specific labor needs.

While paralegals do not usually participate in court proceedings, the documents they draft and the research they conduct are essential to their employers’ legal services. Whether they’re investigating the facts of a case, organizing files or helping attorneys prepare for an upcoming trial, paralegals rely on their strong communication and problem solving skills to get the job done. But evaluating these qualifications is no easy task, which is why many law practices prioritize education and real-world experience when recruiting. However, these credentials do not paint a complete picture of an applicant’s value, so it’s important to incorporate hiring strategies that can help fill in the gaps.

Here are a few tips for recruiting your next paralegal:

1) Connect with Colleges and Trade Schools – Unleash the Power of Networking

Don’t get lost in a sea of resumes; instead, tap into the power of networking and forge alliances with local colleges and trade schools.

Whether you are looking for a paralegal with a bachelor’s or associate’s degree, colleges and trade schools are a potential goldmine of talented paralegal candidates! By connecting with the schools’ alumni networks, you can uncover bright stars who might be eager to join your legal team after graduation.

You’ll have the cream of the crop at your fingertips, ready to help you tackle any paralegal challenge.

2) Look for Self-Starters – Embrace the Independence

In the legal world, paralegals often need to flex their solo sidekick muscles and work independently on tasks assigned by their caped crusader attorney. That’s why it’s essential to keep an eye out for self-starters during your hiring process.

Look for candidates with previous roles that involved taking initiative and managing their time wisely. Maybe you’ll find a legal enthusiast with a background in law and a dash of entrepreneurship in their history. Such individuals might just be what you need to keep your legal team soaring high.

3) Prioritize Attention to Detail – Laser Focus Required

Every hiring manager knows that attention to detail is the secret weapon for success. The same goes for paralegals!

They need to be masters of precision while wading through dense legal jargon and crafting court documents with absolute accuracy. Missing a deadline could spell disaster and a single mistake could cost your firm millions!

That’s why you should seek out candidates with above-average reading and writing superpowers. A pre-employment test can be your X-ray vision to identify those with the keenest comprehension and communication skills.

4) The Swiss Army Sidekick – Identifying Superpowers

The best way to uncover a hidden hero? Know exactly what to look for when identifying a stellar paralegal for your team. A talented paralegal needs the following skill sets ready to wield whenever necessary.

Super Sleuth Investigation:

A paralegal’s most potent superpower is their ability to investigate and gather crucial information. They have a keen eye for detail and can comb through mountains of documents, finding the hidden clues that lead to the truth.

Whether it’s researching case law or digging into the background of a witness, their super sleuth skills help uncover the facts that will make or break a case.

Mighty Multitasking:

In the fast-paced world of law, paralegals must have above average cognitive skills with the ability to juggle multiple tasks with ease. They are true masters of multitasking, able to draft legal documents while scheduling appointments and managing court filings simultaneously. Their ability to keep all the plates spinning makes them indispensable members of any legal team.

Laser-Sharp Organization:

Chaos trembles before the organizational powers of a paralegal. They possess a superhuman ability to keep case files, evidence, and deadlines neatly arranged and easily accessible.

Nothing slips through the cracks when a paralegal is on the case!

Incredible Communication:

A paralegal’s communication skills are nothing short of extraordinary. They can speak the language of law with clarity and precision, translating complex legal jargon into plain English for the rest of the team and clients. Their super-powered writing skills produce persuasive legal arguments and crystal-clear documents.

Fearless Time Management:

When the clock is ticking and the pressure is on, paralegals rise to the occasion with fearless time management skills. They know how to prioritize tasks, meet deadlines, and handle unexpected challenges without breaking a sweat.

Tech Whiz Wizardry:

In this digital age, good paralegals wield the power of technology like true sorcerers. They are tech whiz wizards, proficient in legal software, research databases, and electronic document management systems.

Their mastery of technology enhances efficiency and unleashes the full potential of modern legal tools.

Diplomatic Negotiation:

When conflicts arise, paralegals turn on their diplomatic charm. They possess the super skill of negotiation, helping to resolve disputes and find common ground between parties.

With their tact and finesse, they contribute to achieving peaceful resolutions and avoiding costly battles.

Unyielding Ethics:

Every superhero needs a strong moral compass, and paralegals are no exception. They uphold the highest ethical standards, ensuring that justice is pursued with integrity and fairness. Their unwavering commitment to ethical conduct makes them the true guardians of justice.

Crisis Management Mastery:

In the face of crises, good paralegals remain calm in the face of the storm.

They excel at crisis management, swiftly adapting to unexpected situations and providing crucial support to their legal teammates. No matter how intense the situation, paralegals are always ready to handle the heat.

Team Player Extraordinaire:

Paralegals are the ultimate team players. They understand that collaboration and cooperation are the keys to success.

They work seamlessly with attorneys, clients, and other legal professionals, united by a common purpose: to achieve legal triumph!


Remember, paralegals are the backbone of your legal teams. With their support, you can conquer the trickiest legal challenges and uphold justice like the true champions you are.

These tips, along with reliable, customizable, pre-employment testing, will help you build your dream team of paralegal sidekicks who have the skills and expertise necessary to take on any challenge.

Learn more about our skills based assessments by contacting our team and grab a free sample test today!